Sunday, December 7, 2014

Transforming Political Parties

Something that has intrigued me throughout our study of African-American history is the transformation of political parties. Through the Jim Crow and civil rights eras and into the present, it is interesting to track how both the Republican and Democratic parties have responded to African-American voters.

A recent article in The Atlantic, "The Last Southern Democrat," reminded me of this transformation. The story talks about Democrat Mary Landrieu, the senior United States senator from Louisiana. Yesterday, she lost a run-off election to Republican Bill Cassidy. Now, Democrats do not hold "a single governorship, Senate seat, or legislative chamber from the Carolinas to Texas," as the article predicted would happen before the results of the election were announced. While Landrieu was the last Southern Democratic Senator (except for one in Florida), it's slightly unfair to call her the "last Southern Democrat": for example, Memphis's Congressman, Steve Cohen, is a Democrat. However, it's clear to see the stark differences between a region where "Democrats were once so loyal it was said they would vote for a yellow dog before they would vote for a Republican."

In the South as in most of the United States, voting has usually fallen along racial lines. In Louisiana today, "The approximately one-third of the population that is black is overwhelmingly Democratic, but white voters have fled the party. Landrieu, who got 33 percent of the white vote in 2008, drew just 18 percent of whites in last month's primary." A particular race fleeing from a political party is not rare in American history, however.

During Reconstruction, the large majority of African Americans were Republicans. As the party of Abraham Lincoln and the authors of the thirteenth, fourteenth, and fifteenth amendments, this makes sense. Perhaps surprisingly, African Americans were not even allowed to attend Democratic conventions until 1924. In addition to African Americans, the Republican party was also the first to support women's suffrage. The first African Americans and women elected to Congress were Republicans. How, then, did the Republican party lose its reputation as the "civil rights" party?

During the Great Depression, many African Americans supported Roosevelt's New Deal tactics, especially during his second term. In 1936, he received 71% of the African-American vote. In 1960, about two-thirds of African Americans identified with the Democratic party. Although significantly larger than a few decades before, a large difference still remains between that figure and the 90% who identify with the Democratic party today.

According to one article, Freedom Summer played a large role in the shift of the remaining number of African Americans toward the Democratic party. In particular, the response of many Republicans—and Barry Goldwater in particular—pushed the remaining African Americans away from the Republican party, and toward the party of Lyndon Johnson, who signed the Civil Rights Act into law.

The article on Mary Landrieu helps identify the similar shift of Southern whites away from the Democratic party. Some held on for a fairly long time after Johnson signed the Civil Rights Act. I found the quote in the article from Mike Foster, the former two-term Republican governor of Louisiana (who himself turned away from the Democratic party in 1995), very telling; although the author notes she didn't ask him about race, he said, "I don't think it's racial. . . You know, the races have gotten along down here for years. Look at what's happening in Ferguson right now. We don't have a bunch of people running out in the street hollering about that."

Further reading: 


Saturday, December 6, 2014

A red-white-and-blue problem


Recently I saw a video of  Hillary Clinton speaking on Ferguson. Regardless of my / your opinion on Hillary, her words are powerful.

I decided to transcribe some of it here:

“I applaud President Obama for sending the Attorney General to Ferguson and demanding a thorough and speedy investigation. That’s both appropriate and necessary to find out what happened, to see that justice is done, to help this community begin healing itself. We cannot ignore the inequities that persist in our justice system. Inequities that undermine our most deeply held values of fairness and equality. Watching the recent funeral for Michal Brown, as a mother, as a human being, my heart just broke for his family – because losing a child is every parent’s greatest fear and an unimaginable loss. But I also grieve for that community and for many like it across our country. Behind the dramatic, terrible pictures on television are deep challenges that will be with them and with us, long after the cameras move on.  This is what happens when the bonds of trust and respect that hold any community together fray. Nobody wants to see our streets look like a warzone. Not in America, we are better than that.”

I think this is interesting. Especially the last sentences – “Nobody wants to see our streets look like a warzone – America is better than that.” But are we? Michael Brown, Eric Gardner, there’s a growing list. Maybe America is good at sweeping racial tensions and prejudices under the rug until it gets to these big cases.

Like how she mentions – “Inequities that undermine our most deeply held values of fairness and equality” – can we really say this about America? Do we truly value fairness and equality? I think the history of racism and white supremacy in our country and its continuation to today would say otherwise. 

She had this to say also in another interview:
(I tried to highlight and transcribe most of the most important things she said.)
I like how she addresses more here the actual problem and the reality of our society/nation.
"Now more broadly, each of us has to grapple with some hard truths about race and justice in America. Because despite all the progress we've made together, African Americans, most particularly African-American men, are still more likely to be stopped and searched by police, charged with crimes, and sentenced to longer prison terms," Clinton said Thursday at the Massachusetts Conference for Women in Boston.
"And when one stops and realizes a third of all black men face the prospect of prison during their lifetimes, what devastating consequences that has for their families and their communities and all of us."
"The United States has less than 5% of the world's population, yet we have almost 25% of the world's total prison population. Now, that is not because Americans are more violent or criminal than others around the world; in fact that is far from the facts," Clinton said. "But it is because we have allowed criminal justice system to get out of balance. And I personally hope that these tragedies give us the opportunity to come together as a nation to find our balance again."
The former secretary of state also said she supports President Obama's proposed task force on policing, but that the issue runs deeper than elected officials. 
"These tragedies did not happen in some faraway place. They didn't happen to some other people," she said. "These are our streets, our children, our fellow Americans, and our grief”

I LOVE everything she says here. She speaks to the real problem- what is underneath the drama and the media.
I agree with Hillary especially when she says that these tragedies provide opportunity for us to come together and fix ourselves. To check ourselves before we wreck ourselves.
But most of all, I love her last statement – “these are our streets, our children, our fellow Americans, and our grief.” No one should be indifferent or unaffected. This is not just their problem, this is OUR problem. There is not a “black problem” there is a Red-White-and-Blue Problem.




Friday, December 5, 2014

What We Wanted from Obama.... What exactly is Post-Racial anyways?

     Last night I attended the (incredible) lecture given by Paul C. Taylor last night. He was there to discuss the Obama era, and why it was such a letdown for the American people. Of course he mentioned the current events going on with indictment of cops, but he stayed consistent with discussing Obama - and how it all relates.

    He largely discussed the concept of post-racialism and how it has been applied in the last 8 years. He said there are many ways post-racial is used, the first kind meaning post-racist. He laughed at the concept of post-racism and said anyone with a brain can easily look up statistics and realize that isn't true. (While I agree wholeheartedly with him, I think if he spent a few nights at various white household's Thanksgiving tables, he would realize there are some people who truly believe in the post-racist sentiment. Everyone is free to join me in my Thanksgiving drinking game for one next year: take a sip every time your family says something offensive). He said a better, but still not correct way, to look at the phrase post-racial is to reject the idea of post-racism but acknowledge that *something* has changed racially in our country and try to figure out exactly what. The problem is that many theorists discuss this change as if it is a linear "we were at point A, now we're at point B" type of thinking. We see this faulty linear thinking a lot in historical discussions: the idea that the Civil Rights movement was simply linear, rather than multiple points going on at once.

    He ended discussing the fact that regardless of the definition of post-racial, everyone definitely hoped Obama would serve as some sort of change for America. He paraphrased a quote about Reagan and applied it to Obama in a way that I thought was brilliant: Obama was actually the worst thing that could happen for people of color in America, because he makes it seem like everything is going better, when in fact everything continues to be problematic. I think when Obama rose to power many people sort of saw it as proof that race relations must be doing kind of alright. Unfortunately when Obama has continually spoken to his black communities in a scolding "be more white" kind of fashion, he is anything but progressive.

Thursday, December 4, 2014

Dotson vs. Garner

Let’s talk about the Jarod Dotson case in Knoxville, Tennessee that took place in April of this year. Let’s talk about this 21-year-old man who attended a rowdy University of Tennessee college party — along with about 800 other students — that got busted by the Knoxville Police Department. Let’s talk about how, according to police reports, he resisted arrest. Let’s talk about how Officer Frank Phillips used this allegation to justify a chokehold that resulted in Dotson passing out. Less than 24 hours later, Sheriff Jimmy “JJ” Jones fired Frank Phillips on account of misconduct and unnecessary force and harm.

Fast forward to July of this year. Officer Daniel Pantaleo accused Eric Garner of peddling cigarettes and, deeming it necessary, Pantaleo proceeded in the process of the arrest to hold Garner in a banned chokehold. Garner repeatedly claimed that he could not breathe. Pantaleo failed to release him. Garner died. During the investigation into the happenings of this event, Pantaleo was taken off of the streets, but as soon as he was not indicted he was back on the force in modified duty and will continue to work on modified duty until the higher law is able to put him in jail.

After reading about these two cases, an obvious question came to my mind: Why is it that Phillips was automatically fired from his job after putting a man in an approved chokehold that seemed too harmful but did not result in death and Pantaleo was not fired after putting a man in a banned chokehold that resulted in death? The Dotson case proves that the Garner case (not to mention the Brown case) was a manifestation of our racist society. In connecting these two events and their results, we see that there is an inconsistency with the system. If you didn’t believe that before, believe it now. Two men died within the past few months at the hands of police officers. Two Grand Juries decided against indicting them. One man was choked, albeit unnecessarily, at the hands of a police officer and lived. This police officer was stripped of his title and publicly denounced. What does it mean that some people have to be shaken into recognition by comparing the Brown and Garner cases to a white man’s case? What kind of person really lives in our society?

Burke, Kerry. "NYPD Cop in Eric Garner Chokehold Death Not Indicted." NY Daily News. NYDailyNews.com, 4 Dec. 2014. Web. 5 Dec. 2014.


Greig, Alex, and Helen Pow. "Tennessee Sheriff's Deputy Is FIRED after He Was Caught on Camera Choking an Unresisting College Student until He Passed out." Mail Online. Associated Newspapers, 28 Apr. 2014. Web. 5 Dec. 2014.


Kirkpatrick, Nick. "Knox County Cop Fired Immediately after Photos Show Brutal Choking of Student." Washington Post. The Washington Post, 28 Apr. 2014. Web. 5 Dec. 2014.
  


    

"It looked like a demon": Demonization and hyper-masculinization of Black men in Today's Society


The the first portion of title of my article is a direct quote from the testimony of Officer Darren Wilson describing his confrontation with Mike Brown. In his testimony Wilson says that Brown did not look human and referred to him as  “Hulk Hogan” and a  “demon.” Wilson also said that when he struggled with Brown that the “felt like a five-year old” even though he and Brown were same height. In Wilson eyes, Brown was a super-being incapable of being subdued. The narrative of his testimony sounds extraordinarily similar to the officer’s testimonies in the Rodney King case. The officers described King as the “incredible hulk” and a “Tasmanian devil” when being questioned about their encounter with King.

Both testimonies sound like they would be from the Jim Crow era and were used during speeches to demonize Black men who were accused of rape and lynched. I believe this is a because these descriptions are part of a stereotype known as “the magical negro” which is a trope in film and literature in which a White protagonist is accompanied by a Black character who possesses unexplainable magical powers and in later fiction any Black character that is extremely worldly or wise. Song of the South is seen as one of the first examples of this trope, and many movies starring Morgan Freeman fit this trope.

The trope takes a strange turn and becomes a mix of the magical and the hyper-masculine stereotype of Black men, which is found throughout slavery and Jim Crow and continues in media with Blaxploitation films in the 70’s. Looking at the narratives of the officers and the history that they imply makes me wonder how much stereotypes from these eras still influence people in more recent times. Darren Wilson explained in his testimony that he believed that Brown looked like he was getting stronger with every bullet that went into his body. In any other context the statement would be completely absurd, but what is about this situation that makes is a viable description of another human being?


I’d like start a conversation about this issue, do the effects of the demonization, hyper-masculinization of Black men in America still linger in society so much today that it is used multiple times to explain why Black men are often killed by figure of authority? Blaxploitation films are the most recent example that I believe could still have a strong affect on this issue, not that the Jim Crow era does not still have effects.

Black Vaginas

This week I finished reading Eve Ensler’s A Memory, A Monologue, a Rant, and a Prayer: Writings to Stop Violence Against Women and Girls. Ensler is the creator of the Vagina Monologues as well as the V-Day movement that works to raise awareness surrounding any type of violence against women all over the world. This book is a collection of writings from various authors featured at a festival held in 2006 called “Until the Violence Stops.” There is a piece in the “Rant” section by Kimberle Crenshaw, a scholar at the forefront of Critical Race Theory, titled “Respect.” Crenshaw covers many injustices towards black women in this piece, but for the purpose of this entry I will highlight her focus on the history of America’s economy:
“It wasn’t the Declaration of Independence,
the Constitution,
or the Stars and the Stripes that gave birth to America.
It was the black vagina that laid the golden egg,
or rather, the chattel slave.
That’s right — during America’s formative years, the most
valuable property it produced,
the property that the entire economy was based on,
the property that was mortgaged to build America
was property in slaves.
Twelve billion dollars’ worth.
One can’t begin to fathom it in today’s dollars. And where did
it all come from? Whose vaginas passed this twelve billion
dollars?
Whose vaginas were capitalized, colonized, and amortized all
to give birth to America?” (114)
Crenshaw is absolutely correct. If you look at it from a reproductive standpoint, America’s growth and progress was based on the ability for black women to have children. Their reproductive system was essential. During slavery, they had to give birth, raise children, and do the same work as men. During the Civil Rights Movement, they also held an essential part of the economy. bell hooks writes about their role in the workforce during the Movement. Primarily, they were the ones in the black nuclear families who worked. It was easier for them to find a domestic job than it was for a man to find a good, well-paying job. Oftentimes, if the husband/father of the household could not find a good job, he would remain unemployed. Most black women had to be in the workforce, and they were not happy about it: “Much of the tension in black marriages…was caused by black females’ pressuring men to assume the breadwinner, head-of-the-household role” (hooks 92). Black women were the ones providing the majority of the funding for the family unit and they were also the ones doing their own household’s housework. When Crenshaw calls for some respect in this piece, she deserves it. So often we stereotype black women to be either prostitutes or characters like Aunt Jemima. This ignores their amazing contributions to the foundational American economy. When Crenshaw calls for some respect for black vaginas, she better get it.   

hooks, bell. Ain't I a Woman: Black Women and Feminism. Boston, MA: South End, 1981. 92.   Print.

"Respect." A Memory, a Monologue, a Rant, and a Prayer. Ed. Eve Ensler. New York: Villard,     2007. Print.




Obama's Immigration Speech

On November 20, 2014, President Obama released a statement offering immigration reprieves to immigrants. After some searching, I found this link published by the White House that sums up Obama's plan of action. According to this publication, there are 3 main elements Obama's solution: cracking down on illegal immigration at the border; deporting felons, not families; and accountability--criminal background checks and taxes. At a first glance, this sounds like a great plan. This article also highlights the desire to create a safer border between the US and Mexico by "strengthening the efforts of agencies who work to keep our border secure" and reforming the process of immigration court cases. Furthermore, the article promotes hope by emphasizing their goals of improving the process of naturalization.

The article also presents a seemingly promising new program through the Department of Homeland Security. This program would postpone deportation to parents of US citizens or Lawful Permanent Residents. However, these parents register for the program, must have lived in the US for 5 or more years, must pass a background check, and must pay back taxes. I struggled with the value of this program, especially considering the final component. Many immigrants are poor and/or jobless, and would therefore have difficulty paying back taxes.

 That night, I saw many Facebook posts about the disappointment many individuals felt because their family members would not be eligible. Then I found this site from the Washington Post that explains who actually would be eligible to receive an offer for a delayed deportation. One thing that stood out to me in the text was that particular events had to have taken place by even more particular dates. However, the Washington Post article hypothesizes that these deadlines were "meant to discourage new immigrants from coming in the future, or to dissuade women already here from giving birth with the goal of securing deferrals."

While this is very different from the civil rights we have discussed in class, but I feel the two are similar. Hispanics have been one of the fastest growing minority groups in the US for years. However, many Hispanics feel they are still deserving of many more rights before they are able to be considered a true American citizen. One can also draw similarities between the struggle immigrants are facing to some of the struggles African Americans faced while trying to escape the system of sharecropping set in place during Reconstruction.